Your Local's Guide to West Village

...112 places that prove it is indeed, good to be a West Village Girlie

I spent the better part of a decade daydreaming about living in the West Village. Like so many others who romanticize New York before they ever call it home, I imagined the cobblestone corners, flower box-covered windows, and unhurried walks down tree-lined streets like they were scenes from a movie I hadn’t yet been cast in. And now, four years into calling this seemingly magic neighborhood home, not a day goes by that I don’t feel lucky to wake up here.

Lately, the internet has a lot to say about what it means to be a “West Village girl.” In case you missed it, “It Must Be Nice To Be a West Village Girl” was this week’s cover story of New York Magazine. If you didn’t have the chance to read it yet, the article was an attempt at a takedown piece on the supposed sameness found on our streets. The piece went super viral—and depending on who you ask, made living here more of a punchline than a life goal. (Though, curiously, the article had nothing to say about the men of the West Village—because apparently, gentrification, vanity, and lifestyle curation are only crimes when women commit them? God forbid we critique a 38-year-old dude watching the game at Wogies in his daddy’s hand-me-down Rolex, whose Hinge profile says he’s “still figuring out his dating goals.” No, it’s the women ordering matcha and going on walks on the West Side Highway who are the real menaces...)

But here’s the thing: neighborhoods don’t belong to any one archetype. And the version portrayed in that article? It doesn’t reflect my experience or the experiences of the women I’ve built community with here, from neighbors who’ve lived in my building since before I was born to my fellow members of the West Village Book Club—a group I founded in 2022.

oldnymag

A post shared by @oldnymag

The neighborhood has been mythologized, adored, and dissected for decades, and it will continue to be. As seen above, New York Magazine ran a cover story back in October 1976 titled “The Booming West Village: The Only Place to Live if You Miss Europe.” Of course, it’s changed a bit in fifty years, but that’s the nature of any living, breathing place: it evolves. Even in just a few years, I’ve watched favorite shops close, buzzy new spots open, and beloved characters fade into memory. But what’s remained, for me, is its magnetism. Its charm isn’t just in its aesthetic—it’s in its pace, its sense of community, its ability to feel like a small town tucked inside a very big city.

People come from all over the world to wander these blocks, and I get why. There’s something deeply personal and poetic about the way the West Village makes you feel, whether you’ve lived here for decades or are just visiting for the afternoon. This guide isn’t about gatekeeping; it’s about celebrating the magic of a place I feel endlessly grateful to know, one matcha, martini, and magazine shop at a time.

But, before we dive in, to access the complete version of this and future posts, upgrade today! Paid subscribers of The Sunday Series unlock an exclusive section of paywalled content in each send, access to the full archives (including Your Ultimate Paris Guide, 100 Hotels I’m Dying to Check Into, My Holy Grail Rules for an Overnight Flight, 31 Ideas for Your Next Birthday Trip, A Playbook for How to Make Friends As An Adult, and 16 Prompts for a Personal Quarterly Review), the commenting feature on each post, exclusive giveaways, and more. Plus, your support directly helps ensure this newsletter can continue to grow! Subscriptions are $8/month or less than $7/month if paid annually—also known as less than one fancy Starb*cks order. But don’t let me be the one to tell you why you should upgrade! I’ll leave that to a fellow reader…

"I decided to become a paid subscriber because I appreciate how much info you still give to free subscribers *before* they get to the paywalled part of your email. Counter-intuitive? Maybe! So often a writer turns on paid subs and EVERYTHING is behind the paywall. That's how I thought yours would be too, but I've been pleasantly surprised. It made me make the jump to converting to paid!" – Alison Z., paid subscriber of The Sunday Series

Purely for coffee and good vibes:

• Caffè Aronne (112 Greenwich Avenue) | Where you go when you want your espresso with a splash of Moroccan flair.

• PlantShed (46 8th Ave at Jane Street) | Sip your latte surrounded by lush greenery—there are prime people-watching seats outside that I adore.

• Kobrick Coffee Co. (24 9th Avenue) | A century-old roastery turned café-bar hybrid—start with a cortado, end with a craft cocktail in their indoor or outdoor seating.

• Rosecrans (7 Greenwich Avenue) | Another floral shop meets café where the scent of fresh blooms pairs perfectly with their prime corner seating (this one looking at Jefferson Market Garden and the library!).

For a coffee plus a baked good, a bagel, or a more proper takeaway breakfast:

• L’Appartement 4F (119 W 10th Street) | The croissants are flaky perfection, particularly the pistachio rose, which is practically a love letter in pastry form.

• Mah-Ze-Dahr Bakery (28 Greenwich Avenue) | Home to the kind of pastries that make you believe in butter as a love language.

• Fabrique Bakery (348 W 14th Street) | Swedish cardamom buns that will make you question whether you’re in Stockholm or New York.

• Cafe Panino Mucho Giusto (551 Hudson Street at Perry Street) | A cozy, no-frills spot where the paninis are hot, the coffee is strong, and the vibes are effortlessly European.

• Apollo Bagels (73 Greenwich Ave) | Sourdough bagels so good, they caused a neighborhood line drama that was written about in the New York Times—worth every minute of the wait, though I try to only go on weekdays to avoid said line.

• The Elk (128 Charles Street) | A tucked-away gem on the way to the West Side Highway, where you can grab a turmeric latte while browsing their curated selection of direct-to-consumer products.

For sitting down to linger over tea or coffee…

• Paquita (242 W 10th Street) | A tiny tea haven where vintage charm meets an encyclopedic wall of loose-leaf blends—perfect for when you want to sip slowly and romanticize your life.

• St Jardim (183 W 10th Street) | A sun-drenched corner café that effortlessly transitions from morning lattes to evening natural wines—ideal for lingering with a book (they have a strict no screens policy!) or a friend.

  

• McNulty’s Tea & Coffee Co (109 Christopher Street) | A century-old shop where the scent of global teas and coffees hits you before the door even closes behind you.

• Greenwich Letterpress (15 Christopher Street) | A delightful stationery boutique run by sisters, offering witty cards and custom letterpress that make snail mail exciting again.

• Goods For the Study (50 W 8th Street) | A stationery lover's paradise where you can find everything from sleek pens to chic notebooks—perfect for elevating your desk game or finding that thoughtful gift.

• Big Night (236 W 10th Street) | A treasure trove for the host(ess) with the mostest—think chic tableware and gourmet goodies that turn any night into a big one.

• Murray’s Cheese (254 Bleecker Street) | An iconic cheese shop that's been delighting dairy lovers since 1962—perfect to stock up for a park picnic (park recs below!).

• Travelers Poets & Friends (457 6th Avenue) | A cozy Italian café and market where you can sip espresso, browse artisanal goods, and nab fresh pastas.

• C.O. Bigelow Chemists (414 6th Avenue) | America’s oldest apothecary, dispensing remedies and beauty secrets since 1838—because some things never go out of style, like their epic selection of claw clips.